Files
HealthLog/docs/audit/v146-summary.md
T
Marc-André BombeckandClaude Opus 4.7 2f7f487228 fix(ai): Codex OAuth flow — correct issuer + api-key exchange
The "Connect with ChatGPT" button never actually completed an OAuth
flow. The implementation hit `chatgpt.com/authorize` and
`chatgpt.com/oauth/token`, which are not OAuth endpoints — ChatGPT
silently rendered its normal web app, dropped our params on the
floor, and the user landed on a regular logged-in chat session with
nothing else happening. There was no error and no callback, which is
why the regression survived multiple releases.

The canonical issuer for ChatGPT-OAuth is `auth.openai.com`. The
official `openai/codex` CLI confirms this in
`codex-rs/login/src/auth/manager.rs` and `codex-rs/login/src/server.rs`.
The flow is also slightly more involved than a vanilla PKCE
authorisation:

  1. PKCE authorize against `auth.openai.com/oauth/authorize` with the
     `openid profile email offline_access api.connectors.read
     api.connectors.invoke` scope set, plus `id_token_add_organizations`
     and `codex_cli_simplified_flow` flags so the resulting `id_token`
     carries the ChatGPT-subscription claims.
  2. Token exchange against `auth.openai.com/oauth/token` (form-
     urlencoded body, NOT JSON) yields `{ id_token, access_token,
     refresh_token }`.
  3. **Second token exchange** with grant
     `urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:token-exchange`, swapping the
     `id_token` for an OpenAI API key (`requested_token=openai-api-key`).
     This key bills against the ChatGPT subscription rather than a
     separate API plan — exactly what the v1.2/v1.3 design intended.
  4. HealthLog stores the API key in `codexAccessTokenEncrypted`
     (re-purposing the existing column to avoid a migration) and the
     OAuth refresh token in `codexRefreshTokenEncrypted`. When the
     key is about to age out we refresh + re-exchange transparently
     before the next request.

The downstream provider is now a regular `OpenAIClient` tagged with
`providerType: "codex"` so logs and analytics still distinguish
ChatGPT-subscription billing from plain BYOK. The bespoke
`codex-client.ts` (which hit the chatgpt.com/backend-api/codex/responses
endpoint with the OAuth access token) is still on disk for now so the
prisma columns and the provider tag stay stable, but is unreferenced
by the active path.

The public Codex CLI client ID `app_EMoamEEZ73f0CkXaXp7hrann` is
shipped as a default; operators who registered a private OAuth app
with OpenAI can override via `CODEX_OAUTH_CLIENT_ID`. The
`isCodexOAuthConfigured()` gate is a no-op now because the default
always has a value, so the UI surface no longer silently hides the
"Connect with ChatGPT" button.

Tests cover the new shape end-to-end: PKCE generation, the
authorize-URL parameters, the form-encoded token exchange, the
api-key exchange, the refresh path, and the encrypt/decrypt
round-trip. The provider integration test is updated to expect a
`providerType: "codex"` OpenAIClient instead of the legacy
`CodexClient`.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-05-09 09:31:13 +02:00

215 lines
11 KiB
Markdown

# HealthLog v1.4.6 — Marathon Summary
## Marc-Brief (DE, ≤ 200 Wörter)
✅ **v1.4.6 ist live** auf `https://healthlog.bombeck.io` — Container neu,
Image-Digest `sha256:dcfa70be96a9…` (vorher v1.4.5: `0fc06b0b69d9…`).
🆕 **Was neu ist**
- **Charts aggregieren bei Langzeit-Range** automatisch zu
Wochen- (91-730 Tage) bzw. Monatsdurchschnitt (>730 Tage). Chip im
Chart-Header zeigt den aktiven Bucket.
- **KI sieht jetzt 3 Jahre Historie** pro Karte: 360 Tageswerte +
24 Monatswerte, mit Token-Budget-Wächter (Fallback 180 Tage bei
laute Konten).
🔧 **Was repariert wurde**
- **Tile-Strip füllt jetzt aus** (T1) und Hierarchie ist sichtbar
(T2: `--muted-foreground` jetzt wirklich gedämpft, AA-Kontrast).
- **KI-Empfehlung parst `metric:`-Tokens** (T3) — keine rohen Tokens
mehr im Hero-Block.
- **AI-Provider-Leak geschlossen** (T4): Wechsel LOCAL → OPENAI
schickt den Cloud-Key nicht mehr an die alte LAN-URL.
- **`/api/insights/generate` 502 → 422** (T5) — Cloudflare-HTML-Trap weg.
- **Admin-Buttons springen zum richtigen Anker** (T6) statt nach oben.
- **Bug-Report-Toggle wirkt jetzt** (T7) am API-Gate UND in der UI.
- **Audit-Log überlebt den Daten-Wipe** (T8).
- 20 Tier-2-Polish-Items (Typografie, Farben, i18n, Strukturfehler).
⚠️ **Hard-Reload** mit `Cmd+Shift+R` damit der neue Service-Worker greift.
📚 **Docs aktualisiert** — `docs.healthlog.dev` jetzt auf v1.4.6, neue
Seiten zu Native-API, Skalierung, Dashboard-Customization.
🎯 **v1.5-Backlog** unten in diesem Dokument.
---
## What landed
27 commits since `e8f4820` (v1.4.5 head).
### Tier 1 — release blockers (`docs/audit/v146-findings.md`)
| ID | Commit | Summary |
| ----- | --------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------ |
| T1+T2 | `8aae7d6` | tile fill + muted-foreground hierarchy |
| T3 | `a75fbc6` | primary recommendation parses chart tokens |
| T4 | `eba898f` | aiBaseUrl provider-leak guard + tests |
| T5 | `c8ee28d` | insights/generate parse error 502 → 422 |
| T6 | `4aeb8c9` | admin status-card hrefs + tightened test |
| T7 | `31959e4` | bug-report toggle now blocks /api/feedback + UI |
| T8 | `c3ca861` | data-wipe preserves AuditLog + scope copy |
| T9 | `1adda80` | per-card insight window 360 daily + 24 monthly across 7 generators |
### New feature
| Commit | Summary |
| --------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `6a64df0` | chart bucketing for ranges > 1y (weekly / monthly aggregation + chip) |
### Tier 2 — polish
| Commit | Summary |
| --------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `fda8dd8` | trend-card P1-P5 (tabular nums, KPI typography, padding parity, always-show avgs) |
| `dc6db82` | P6 + P10 (visible muted subtitle, medications card padding) |
| `5c884b3` | P7-P9 (mobile nav buffer, trend-hint title, font-mono drop) |
| `e903d9a` | P11 — redactSecrets sk-/sk-ant- |
| `c7b6005` | P12 — idempotency body-content guard |
| `4a159d2` | P13 — rate-limit moved below cache return |
| `dcc697c` | P14 — codex-client structured errors |
| `89b5b80` | P15+P16 — drop unreleased presets, i18n the AI section |
| `505f318` | P17 — feedback badges → dracula tokens |
| `86a4b52` | P18 — danger-zone colour follows mutation state |
| `2654337` | P19 — useSystemStatus / useAdminSettings isError UI |
| `dc4507a` | P20 — status-overview Promise.allSettled |
### CI / housekeeping
| Commit | Summary |
| --------- | ------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `bcd1de4` | drop e2e pnpm-version override (was failing every run) |
| `46e686f` | switch e2e mobile project to chromium + repair spec flakiness |
| `02b9955` | repo-wide prettier sweep before tag |
| `ecca54d` | `.planning` bootstrap |
### Multi-agent QA follow-ups
| Commit | Summary |
| --------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `6757518` | qa pass — orange→dracula tokens, status-card cta copy honest, idempotency `sk-` regex tightening with false-positive tests |
### Release
| Commit | Summary |
| --------- | -------------------------------------------------------- |
| `a852612` | `chore(release): v1.4.6` (package.json bump + CHANGELOG) |
## What was deferred (v1.5 backlog)
From the multi-agent QA pass:
1. **Notification-channel scope of "Wipe all data"** — `NotificationChannel`,
`PushSubscription`, `TelegramScheduledDeletion`, and `Feedback` rows
survive the wipe even though `User.telegramBotToken` etc. are nulled.
Pre-existing scope drift; the encrypted Telegram bot token in
`NotificationChannel.config` survives. Not introduced by v1.4.6.
Fix: extend the data-wipe transaction.
2. **Berlin TZ DST math in cross-metric joins** — `bucketSeries`'s
`dayOffset` reverse mapping (used by BP-pair / weight↔BP /
medication-adherence joins) computes `now - dayOffset·86_400_000`
which is wrong on DST boundaries. Affects ~2 days/year of
miscredited data — low blast-radius, but should be exposed via a
helper from `bucket-series.ts` to centralise the conversion.
3. **`status-card-grid` test brittleness** — the test maintains a
hand-curated list of section IDs; the findings doc recommended
rendering `<AdminPage />` and asserting via DOM. v1.5 follow-up.
4. **`redactSecrets` regex word-boundary** — current `/sk-(?:ant-)?[A-Za-z0-9_-]+/`
over-matches "task-force", "risk-management" etc. Not a security
issue (over-redaction is the safe failure mode), purely a log
readability concern.
5. **`/api/insights/generate` provider-error → 500** — when the admin
OpenAI key is invalid, the route propagates "OpenAI request failed
(401)" up to the apiHandler which maps to a generic 500. T5 fixed
only the parse-error branch. v1.5: catch provider-side errors and
map to 422/503 with a readable body.
6. **`useAdminSettings` / `useSystemStatus` test coverage** — the new
`isError` UI added in P19 has no integration test covering the
error path. Manual verification only.
7. **Backups dedicated admin section** — currently the "Backups"
status-card jumps to `#section-system-status` because no dedicated
backups view exists. Re-labelled honestly to "Open system status"
in v1.4.6; v1.5 should add the actual backups view.
## CI / test status
- `pnpm typecheck` — clean
- `pnpm lint` — 0 errors / 12 warnings (pre-existing `_param`-style
unused vars; not in scope to refactor)
- `pnpm format:check` — clean (sweep landed in `02b9955`)
- `pnpm test` — 714 passed
- `pnpm test:integration` — 10 passed (testcontainers)
- `pnpm build` — fails locally on Node 25 due to a Turbopack
AsyncLocalStorage / Reflect.get bug. CI Docker image (Node 22)
builds cleanly — that is the canonical release path.
- `e2e` workflow — fixed and pushed; the run on the v1.4.6 SHA was
still pending at deploy time. Per the marathon spec, e2e green is
not a hard gate.
## Production state
- URL: `https://healthlog.bombeck.io`
- `/api/version`: `1.4.6` ✓
- Image SHA: `sha256:dcfa70be96a955a554f8c943a1d954fa8a23f49896047f88658b62df72f60ba8`
- Previous (v1.4.5): `sha256:0fc06b0b69d987f6498bd5f9224e316cbcee91cafaf098eb738f43061fcc6ffc`
- Container: `app-pg8wggwogo8c4gc4ks0kk4ss-005603315572`, healthy
- `/api/ai/test` smoke with fake key: returns **422** with readable
JSON body ✓ (Cloudflare passthrough confirmed).
### Coolify-deploy quirk worth noting
The first `mcp__coolify-apps01__deploy` call with `force: true`
finished in 21 seconds (`fxwl88wohhbl7f730nfv0kk1`) and reported
"Removing old containers / Starting new application", but the running
container still ran the old `0fc06b0b…` image — Coolify's compose-pull
took ~250 ms which is far too short to actually pull a new image, and
the container ID stayed the same. A manual
`docker compose pull && docker compose up -d app` on the host pulled
the new digest cleanly and the container then recreated. End state
matches the desired SHA, but Coolify's force-rebuild semantics on
this app instance look unreliable. Worth a v1.5 follow-up to
reproduce and report upstream.
## Docs / landing
Both repos pushed. See agent report for commit list. Highlights:
- `healthlog-docs`: 8 commits bringing site from v1.2 → v1.4.6.
New pages: `api/native-clients.mdx`, `self-hosting/scaling.mdx`,
`features/dashboard-customization.mdx`. Existing pages refreshed
for v1.3-v1.4 features.
- `healthlog-landing`: single commit `ebb03f9` bumping
`softwareVersion` 1.3.3 → 1.4.6 and expanding the JSON-LD
`featureList`. Screenshots untouched (Marc's call to refresh in
daylight).
## GitHub releases
Backfilled `v1.4.2`, `v1.4.3`, `v1.4.4`, `v1.4.5`, **`v1.4.6`** at
https://github.com/MBombeck/HealthLog/releases — each with the
canonical CHANGELOG block as release notes.
## QA agent reports — full text
Stored in commit messages of `6757518` (the QA-pass follow-up
commit). Three agents ran in parallel against the v1.4.6 diff:
- **superpowers:code-reviewer** — no CRITICAL, 3 HIGH (DST math,
idempotency `sk-` substring, monthly bucket label semantics).
All triaged: `sk-` regex fixed; rest deferred.
- **Plan agent (security)** — no CRITICAL/HIGH. M1 (notification-
channel data-wipe scope) deferred. T4/T7/T8/P11/P12 cleared.
- **Plan agent (design)** — no CRITICAL, 2 HIGH (orange tokens in
ai-section.tsx, status-card cta copy honesty). Both fixed.
---
## Hard-Reload reminder
`Cmd+Shift+R` (Mac) / `Ctrl+Shift+R` (Linux/Win) so the new
service-worker fetches fresh `_next/static` chunks. Without it the
client may stay on the v1.4.5 bundle for up to a navigation cycle.