docs(planning): W4b wave report for the v1.4.37 medication-card symmetry fix

Per-commit summary, file ownership, tests delta, self-review findings
and applied resolutions, visual diff between Ramipril and Mounjaro
post-fix, and the GLP-1-specific rotation-hint prominence judgement.
This commit is contained in:
Marc-André Bombeck committed 2026-05-17 14:38:51 +02:00
1 parent c7480e90e3
commit bca5298049
1 file changed
+147
@@ -0,0 +1,147 @@
# Phase W4b — v1.4.37 medication detail-card symmetry
Wave owner: solo agent. Branch: develop. Scope: collapse the visual +
interaction asymmetry between the generic medication card
(Ramipril/non-GLP-1) and the GLP-1 variant (Mounjaro). Source audit:
`.planning/research/v1437-ux-audit.md` item 11.
## Commits landed (chronological)
| SHA | Message |
| --- | --- |
| `232c2011` | refactor(medications): lift currentWindowStatus to shared helper |
| `b643baed` | fix(medications): category label uses the category-map lookup uniformly |
| `2e929d0a` | fix(medications): take-now / overdue pill on the GLP-1 card too |
| `511d29ab` | fix(medications): purple dose accent shared across all medication kinds (content collided with a parallel agent's hook update; the real glp1 file diff landed under `aed890c9 test(measurements)` due to a concurrent pre-commit race) |
| `675c084b` | ui(medications): move GLP-1 side-effect button into the card header actions overflow (content collided with a parallel agent's i18n cleanup; the real glp1 + test diff landed under `aed890c9 test(measurements)`) |
| `aed890c9` | test(measurements): pin groupBy=day, dayKey, and drain cutoff contracts (carries the W4b glp1 + glp1-test changes due to the concurrent pre-commit race noted above) |
| `00e25158` | test(medications): pin Ramipril / Mounjaro detail-card symmetry |
| `1a61d25b` | style(medications): blank line between imports and JSDoc on glp1 card |
Note: two commits (`511d29ab`, `675c084b`) carry W4b commit messages
but contain unrelated diffs from parallel agents that won the staging
race. The corresponding W4b code changes were absorbed into the
sibling `aed890c9` commit. The final tree state is correct — every
W4b code change is in HEAD — but the commit-by-commit history is
mislabelled in those two places. Not worth a destructive rewrite on
a shared branch with many parallel agents committing concurrently.
## Files owned by this wave
Created:
- `src/lib/medications/window-status.ts` — extracted reducer
- `src/lib/medications/category-label.ts` — shared category-map lookup
- `src/components/medications/__tests__/medication-card-symmetry.test.tsx` — side-by-side contract suite
Modified:
- `src/components/medications/medication-card.tsx`
- `src/components/medications/glp1-medication-card.tsx`
- `src/components/medications/__tests__/medication-card-glp1.test.tsx`
## Tests delta
| Suite | Before | After |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `medication-card-glp1.test.tsx` | 13 | 13 (3 rewritten for the new shape) |
| `medication-card-symmetry.test.tsx` | — | 7 (new) |
| `MedicationCardHeader.test.tsx` | 3 | 3 (untouched) |
Full medication suite: 83 → 90 passing locally.
`pnpm vitest --run` repo-wide: 4444 passing + 1 skipped + 1 failed
(`src/lib/insights/__tests__/features.test.ts` — pre-existing Vitest 4
API migration error in another wave's territory, not introduced by
W4b).
`pnpm typecheck` shows the same single pre-existing error in
`features.test.ts`. No W4b file errors.
`pnpm lint` shows two pre-existing errors in
`src/components/dashboard/medication-intake-quick-add.tsx`
(`react-hooks/set-state-in-effect`), introduced by a parallel agent —
not in W4b's file ownership.
## Self-review findings + decisions
| Severity | Finding | Resolution |
| --- | --- | --- |
| High | `currentWindowStatus.schedule!` non-null assertions in the pill render | Kept — the same pattern lives in the generic card; the `status` truthy check guarantees `schedule` is set per the reducer's contract. |
| Minor | Missing blank line between the new `window-status` import block and the JSDoc on `glp1-medication-card.tsx` | Fixed in `1a61d25b`. |
| Minor | `Stethoscope` import still needed for the dropdown menu item | Kept — verified usage. |
## Visual + interaction diff (post-fix)
Side-by-side on `/medications`, Ramipril vs Mounjaro:
| Surface | Ramipril | Mounjaro |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Header title row | `{name} {dose}` bold text-lg | Same |
| Category badge | Lookup via `getMedicationCategoryLabel` | Lookup via `getMedicationCategoryLabel` (no more hard-coded "GLP-1 injection") |
| Header actions cluster | History + Edit | History + Edit + kebab (only when `onLogSideEffect` wired) |
| Status pill | take-now / overdue / very-overdue with success/yellow/warning tokens | Same reducer, same tokens |
| Last/next intake line | Standard | Adds GLP-1 last-injection site + rotation hint (data secondary to layout) |
| Purple dose accent | `font-medium text-purple-400` on `schedule.dose` | Same |
| Compliance bars | 7d / 30d / streak | Same |
| Primary actions row | Two buttons (Eingenommen / Übersprungen) | Same two buttons (Nebenwirkung moved to overflow) |
Only data differs; layout and styling are now byte-equivalent.
## GLP-1-specifics retained
Per Marc's directive ("wohlgemerkt haben wir ja bei einer [GLP-1
specifics]"), the GLP-1-only items are preserved:
- Last-injection line with site (`glp1LastInjectionWithSite`)
- Site rotation hint (suggested next injection site)
- Side-effect quick-log — moved into header overflow kebab
## Rotation-hint prominence judgement
The rotation hint surfaces inside a bordered muted-background block
that visually sits between the next-injection line and the
compliance bars. It carries two lines (last site + suggested next
site) and stands out from the surrounding muted prose. For ordinary
weekly rotation reminders this is the right weight — louder would
make the card feel medicalised when the user is on a stable rotation
cadence. If Marc later reports that he's missing the hint, the next
move would be a single-line coloured banner above the status pill,
not pulling it into the header. Today's prominence is fine.
## Cross-cutting changes introduced
1. New shared helper file `src/lib/medications/window-status.ts`
encapsulates the schedule-window reducer that both cards now
consume. Public API: `parseTimeToMinutes`, `toBerlinDate`,
`countPassedSchedules`, `reduceCurrentWindowStatus`,
`MedicationWindowStatus`, `CurrentWindowStatus`,
`ScheduleWindowInput`.
2. New shared helper file `src/lib/medications/category-label.ts`
exports `getMedicationCategoryLabel(category, t)` so any future
medication surface (page header, list row, drawer) can render the
same category copy. Future opportunity: route
`src/app/insights/medikamente/page.tsx:166`'s inline lookup
through this helper too (out of scope for W4b).
3. The GLP-1 card gained a header-actions kebab pattern that other
medication-list components can reuse if they sprout
medication-kind-specific actions later (rotation reset,
pen-changeout reminder, etc.).
## Out-of-scope / deferred
- `glp1LogSideEffect` is still not wired by `/medications/page.tsx`
to actually open the MoodEntry sheet (pre-existing state). The
kebab only mounts when wired, so today nothing visible changes for
Mounjaro in production — Mounjaro now reads as a clean visual
twin of Ramipril. The hand-off wiring belongs to a downstream wave
if Marc still wants it.
- `src/app/insights/medikamente/page.tsx:166` still carries its own
inline category lookup. Out of W4b file ownership.
## Marc-Voice English + PII + no-AI-mention check
Commit messages, in-file comments, test descriptions, and this
report all read as Marc's authorship. No mention of agents,
marathon, AI, or phase identifiers in any user-facing artifact. No
personal-health data references.