The scope picker arrived with the standard doctor's report already ticked,
so someone who opened the panel and pressed Generate sent material they
never chose. Nothing is selected now until a person selects it.
The template keeps its definition and loses its automatic application: it
sits on a button at the top of the picker, named, on both surfaces that
mount the picker, and it stays there so the standard set can be restored
after experimenting. One click still gets a complete doctor's report.
Generate and the share-link create refuse an empty scope, with the scope
line beside them saying what to do rather than reporting a failure after
the press; the line also describes the control, so the disabled state is
not silent for a screen reader.
Settings → Gesundheitsakte mounts the one scope picker twice: the export
panel at the top, the share-link create form under `#sharing`. Sharing the
component is deliberate, but it also meant every test id inside it resolved
to two elements on that page, so nothing in the picker could be addressed
without guessing which one you got.
The picker now takes a required `surface` and every id under it ends with
that surface — `report-group-row-vitals-export` and
`report-group-row-vitals-share` are two controls and read as two controls.
The summary line beside each picker follows the same rule. A third mount
picks a value and stays addressable by construction.
Migration 0273 revokes every live record share link minted before the selection
model, because their frozen scope was "everything except mood and cycle" — a
scope nobody chose. The owner has to see why the link stopped and be able to
replace it without retyping what they already decided, or a deliberate closure
reads as a fault. The list now names that state, says why in one sentence, and
offers a replacement that carries the label, the window and the lifetime
across, leaving exactly the decision that link never carried.
Writing the test for it found a defect in the picker. The group count and the
group checkbox read the catalogue's group rather than the leaves the surface
actually renders, so on the share-link form — where the insurance leaf is
hidden because the server refuses it — the identity row read "1/2" and drew
itself half-selected over a leaf the owner could neither see nor reach, and its
checkbox would have tried to add it. The three helpers take the rendered leaves
now, so a control cannot describe more than it offers.
Two downloads under the token — the FHIR document Bundle and the clinical PDF —
behind the same unlock cookie the document route enforces, serving exactly the
link's frozen selection. That is what the removed FHIR toggle promised, in the
form a practice actually uses: open the link, unlock it, save the file. No new
credential type, no new scope, no mint path that does not exist.
The gate is the document route's, step for step: the same live check, the same
token-scoped cookie, the same blunt 404 for every miss class so a probe cannot
tell "no such link" from "revoked" from "documents-only". It differs in one
number, because generating a bundle is far more expensive than serving a stored
blob and must not share a budget with it. Each download writes its own audit
row. The scope cannot exceed the page's: both resolve the same frozen leaf list
through the same resolver, and the insurance leaf is refused at create, so the
insurance number cannot reach this path at all.
The MCP doctor-visit summary stops claiming presence it cannot support. An
account whose owner never saved a report selection resolves to the empty one on
that surface, and an empty scope produces an empty payload — which now reads as
{ present: false, reason }, the same sentinel the other reads use, instead of a
record with every section quietly missing.
Mutation-checked: removing the unlock check, the rate limit, the documents-only
guard or the audit row reddens its own case; pointing the bucket at the document
route's key reddens the bucket assertion; making presence unconditional reddens
the absence case.
The saved profile's shape moves out of the module that reads the row. The panel
is a client component and parses the blob from the /me payload; importing the
reader dragged the database client into the browser bundle, which typecheck and
the unit suite both pass and only `next build` catches.
Five layers, because the defect had five places to hide.
The catalogue guard checks what the compiler cannot state: every leaf resolves
a label a human can read, every group resolves one, the fenced tier stays last,
and the shipped template intersects the fence at nothing.
The selection guard pins the three minting functions against each other. A
stored blob this build cannot read resolves to the empty selection, never to a
default set — that is what makes the revoked legacy links revocable rather than
silently re-scoped. A request naming an id the server does not know is refused
by name rather than dropped, because dropping it would narrow a scope the
caller did express.
The egress guard freezes the set of aggregator callers with the source of each
one's selection written down. The required brand-typed parameter already stops
a new path compiling without an answer; this stops one being added without a
human writing the answer down, which is the moment a reviewer asks the
question.
The behavioural sweep aggregates every leaf in and out against a fixture that
carries a row for each, and asserts the payload differs. It is parametrised
over the catalogue, so a leaf added later is covered the day it is added. Its
positive control asserts the all-on payload is genuinely populated first, so a
"no difference" result means the gate is inert and not that the account is
empty. Beside it: an unmapped measurement type is excluded rather than passed
through, no table behind an unchosen leaf is queried at all, and an empty
selection produces an empty record.
The artefact layer runs the real route and reads what comes out — the FHIR
bundle, the PDF text and the zip's contents — with a positive control beside
every exclusion.
Mutation-checked: making the gate admit everything reddens the sweep for every
leaf; passing an unmapped type through reddens the fail-closed case; dropping
the mood query's condition reddens the zero-read case; returning the BMI
unconditionally reddens the sweep naming BODY_MASS_INDEX; adding a fenced leaf
to the template reddens the purity guard; removing the panel's seeding block
reddens the first-run and repeat-run cases; dropping the insurance refusal
reddens the share-link case; adding a caller outside the frozen list reddens
the egress guard naming the file.
The panel suite grew past the practice name it was written for and is renamed
for what it now covers: the three states, the fenced tier having no group
control, and the scope line naming its sensitive inclusions.
Integration coverage moves to the leaf model, including the case this release
exists for: an account with data in every domain and a caller that named
nothing gets an empty record.
The OpenAPI contract catches up with the routes — the required selection, the
refused keys, the share summary's new fields, the moved `Patient/$everything`,
the Coverage search and the five typed reads.
The export panel rendered twenty flat switches behind a collapsed disclosure,
and the share-link form rendered none at all — it posted whatever the create
schema defaulted to. Both now mount the same picker: twelve named groups, a
count on each, the leaf grid one chevron away, and a fenced tier below a
separator.
The fence is mechanical, not a label. The sensitive tier has no group
checkbox, so no single control anywhere in the picker can turn on more than
one of mood, cycle, family history, PHQ-9, GAD-7, WHO-5 or SCI at a time.
There is no select-all. The shipped template contains none of them. And the
scope line under the button restates every sensitive inclusion by name rather
than folding it into a count, because a number cannot be checked at a glance
and "incl. Mood, PHQ-9" can.
First run opens expanded with the named standard template applied and the
fenced tier visibly empty, so the user presses Generate having seen twelve
named groups. Every later run opens collapsed carrying their own last
selection, which makes the waiting-room path two interactions.
Only leaves are ever stored. A group's checkbox is derived from its leaves, so
the two cannot disagree, and switching a group off and back on inside one
session restores the pattern instead of flooding it.
The cycle export card is deleted. It posted empty groups under a docblock
claiming every other section was off, and empty groups resolved to the
defaults — so a "cycle only" download carried weight, blood pressure, pulse,
oxygen saturation, body fat, body composition, the medication list, adherence,
labs, allergies and family history. Cycle is a fenced leaf in the one picker
now, reachable for the PDF as well as for FHIR, which is more than the card
offered.
The panel gains a 30-day preset and a custom window, and its error line says
what went wrong instead of interpolating a status code.
The Checkbox primitive learns the indeterminate state it already had the Radix
support for. A partly-selected group drawn as unchecked would say "none of
this is included", which on this surface is a false statement about what
leaves the instance.
Marc-André Bombeck